Table of contents
Get insights delivered straight into your inbox every week!

Ultimate Guide to A/B Testing Cold Emails in 2025

A/B testing cold emails is a simple way to improve your outreach campaigns by testing different email elements, like subject lines or call-to-actions, to see what works best. In 2025, with smarter email filters and savvier prospects, this technique is more important than ever to stand out in crowded inboxes. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Why It Matters: Competition is fierce. Personalized subject lines increase open rates by 26%, and segmentation boosts engagement for over 90% of marketers.
  • What to Test: Focus on subject lines, email body content, CTAs, sender names, and send times. For example, testing personalized vs. generic subject lines can lead to 22% higher open rates.
  • How to Test: Change one variable at a time, split your list evenly, and ensure a large enough sample size (at least 100–200 prospects). Analyze metrics like open rates, clicks, and replies.
  • Tools You Need: Platforms like Mailforge simplify email setup and testing at scale, ensuring high deliverability and accurate results.

A/B testing isn’t just about quick fixes - it’s about consistently refining your strategy to achieve better results over time. Start small, track your data, and build on what works.

What to Test in Your Cold Emails

When it comes to cold email campaigns, focusing on the elements that influence performance the most is key. Each part of your email serves a specific purpose, and testing them systematically helps you refine your approach and make smarter decisions. Below, we’ll break down the main components you should be testing to improve your campaign results.

Subject Lines

Subject lines are like the front door to your email - they’re the first thing recipients see, and they heavily influence whether your email gets opened. In fact, 47% of people open an email based solely on the subject line.

Try experimenting with different styles, such as curiosity-driven lines versus benefit-focused ones. For example, a curiosity-driven subject like "Can You Guess the Top Strategy Boosting Sales in 2023?" increased open rates by 15% and overall engagement by 7% in one case study. On the other hand, straightforward, benefit-focused lines can also be effective. Keep subject lines under 60 characters for maximum impact.

Personalization is another area to test - subject lines that include personalized details can boost open rates by 22%. However, be cautious with your wording. For instance, including "newsletter" can reduce open rates by 18.7%, while mentioning a free offer has been shown to increase open rates by 10%. Also, avoid spammy words that could trigger filters, and use action-oriented language to create urgency.

Email Body Content

Once your email is opened, the body content determines whether the recipient stays engaged. This is where you can test different writing styles to see what resonates. Some audiences prefer concise, business-focused emails, while others respond better to a conversational tone that feels more personal.

You can also experiment with email length. Compare short messages (under 100 words) with longer, more detailed ones to learn what your audience prefers. Additionally, test different formats - single-paragraph emails versus those broken into multiple paragraphs or bullet points - to see which is easier for recipients to read. Personalization is another critical factor. Try basic personalization, like using the recipient's name, versus more detailed personalization that references specific events, achievements, or pain points relevant to them.

Call-to-Action (CTA)

The call-to-action (CTA) is where you ask for something - whether it’s a meeting, feedback, or a simple reply - and it’s crucial for driving conversions. Test different styles of CTAs to see what works best. For example, compare a direct request like "Are you available for a 15-minute call this Thursday?" with a softer approach like "Would it make sense to explore this further?"

Placement can also make a difference. Try putting the CTA early in the email versus at the end to see which gets better results. Additionally, experiment with question-based CTAs versus statement-based ones. Be specific - asking for a "15-minute call" is often more effective than a vague "quick chat." You might also test alternative asks, like requesting feedback or a yes/no response, as these can sometimes drive higher engagement.

Sender Name and Signature

The sender name and signature play a big role in building trust. Test formal sender names, such as "John Smith, VP of Sales", against more casual options like "John from ABC Company." You might find that one style resonates better with your audience.

Similarly, experiment with your email signature. A minimal signature that includes just your name and company might feel more approachable, while a detailed signature with your title, phone number, and social media links can add credibility. You can also test using just your first name versus your full name to see which feels more relatable and trustworthy to recipients.

Send Time and Frequency

Timing can make or break your email’s performance. Test sending emails at different times of the day - morning (8–10 AM), afternoon (2–4 PM), and evening (6–8 PM) - to find your audience’s peak engagement window. For example, 58% of U.S. consumers check their emails first thing in the morning. Day of the week matters too - emails sent on Sundays have the highest open rates at 18.7%, while Thursdays see the lowest open rates and the highest unsubscribe rates.

Don’t forget to consider your audience’s time zones and daily routines. Also, test follow-up frequency. While you want to stay top of mind, you don’t want to overwhelm your recipients. Interestingly, 55% of responses come from follow-up emails, so finding the right balance is essential.

How to Run A/B Tests Step by Step

Running A/B tests effectively requires a structured plan that delivers meaningful insights for your cold email campaigns. Each step builds on the previous one, creating a process that ensures reliable results. Here's how to approach A/B testing to refine your email strategy.

Set Clear Goals

Before diving into testing, define what success looks like. Vague goals like "improve performance" won't cut it. Instead, focus on specific and measurable objectives that align with your campaign's purpose.

For instance, frame your hypothesis as: "If I do X, then Y will happen". This forces you to think through both your expectations and the reasoning behind them.

Set realistic targets. For example, aim for a 5% increase in open rates or 10 additional conversions. If you're testing subject lines, track open rates; for changes to your call-to-action, focus on click-through or reply rates. The metrics you monitor should directly relate to the element being tested.

It's also important to consider your current baseline. If your open rate is 40%, expecting a 15% improvement to reach 46% is far more achievable than aiming for an unrealistic leap.

Test One Thing at a Time

A common pitfall in A/B testing is changing too many elements at once. If you tweak both the subject line and email body, you won't know which change drove the results.

Stick to testing a single variable at a time. For example, if you want to experiment with subject lines and call-to-action buttons, run separate tests. While this approach might take longer, it ensures your data is clear and actionable.

Here’s an example: A SaaS company tested two subject lines. Version A said, "Boost Your Productivity with [Tool Name]", while Version B asked, "Struggling with Time Management? Try This." By keeping everything else the same, they discovered that Version B led to a 25% higher open rate and a 20% increase in replies. Testing one variable at a time not only identifies what works but also creates a solid foundation for future campaigns.

Split Your Email List Properly

To ensure your results are accurate, split your email list randomly. This way, any performance differences reflect the test itself, not variations in audience characteristics.

Divide your list into equal groups randomly. Most email platforms offer tools to handle this for you.

Make sure your sample size is large enough to produce reliable data. For most campaigns, aim for at least 1,000 to 5,000 subscribers per group. Smaller groups can lead to misleading outcomes due to natural behavior fluctuations.

Also, think carefully about segmentation. Testing too broadly can water down your results, while overly narrow groups might not yield enough data for meaningful insights. Strike a balance by considering demographic, behavioral, or engagement factors relevant to your campaign.

Finally, give your test enough time. Wait 24–72 hours before analyzing results, depending on your send volume and typical engagement patterns. This ensures you capture the full response cycle and avoid premature conclusions.

Analyze Results and Apply Learnings

Once your test concludes, dive into the data to determine whether the results are statistically significant. Small differences might seem promising but could simply be due to chance if your sample size is too small.

Use tools like your email platform's built-in calculators or online resources to confirm statistical significance. For example, a 2% improvement in open rates might look good, but without enough data, it could fall within normal fluctuations.

Focus on the metrics tied to your original goal. If you tested subject lines to boost open rates, prioritize that metric while keeping an eye on secondary data to ensure no negative impact elsewhere.

When you identify a winning variation, integrate it into your ongoing campaigns and document the lessons learned. Understanding why a change worked will help guide your next test. For example, if a subject line emphasizing a pain point resonated with your audience, you might explore variations that highlight other aspects of your message. Each test should build on the last, driving consistent improvements in your campaigns. These incremental insights help refine your approach over time, leading to better results.

Tools and Setup for Large-Scale Testing

Running A/B tests at scale requires a reliable email infrastructure to ensure your messages bypass spam filters and deliver accurate results. Here's how you can establish a dependable foundation for testing at any volume.

Using Mailforge for Email Infrastructure

Mailforge

Setting up traditional email systems can be a time-consuming headache, with hours spent configuring DNS records and SSL certificates. Mailforge simplifies this process, automating everything in minutes to ensure your emails are properly authenticated for top-notch deliverability. Why is this important? If your test emails end up in spam folders due to misconfigured settings, your A/B test results become useless.

"When it comes to cold email infrastructure setup, Mailforge provides 100x improvement! Procedures that usually took hours (setting DKIM, SPF, etc. records) for multiple domains, now take a few minutes." - Karlo Binda, Founder Leadsnack.co

Cost is another area where Mailforge stands out. Compared to Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, which charge around $8.40 and $6.00 per mailbox monthly (totaling $1,680 and $1,200 for 200 mailboxes, respectively), Mailforge offers similar functionality for just $484 per month.

Mailforge's shared infrastructure model is particularly effective for A/B testing. Instead of managing individual IP addresses or domain reputations, you benefit from a shared pool designed specifically for cold outreach. This ensures consistent deliverability across all your test variations.

To further build trust with email providers, Mailforge automatically handles SSL and domain masking, making every sender domain appear legitimate.

"The simplicity and the automation in the buying process of domains, DNS setting, inbox creation, forwarding, etc. Everything in one place... my results had been great since using Mailforge!" - Isabella L., Founder, Let's Fearlessly Grow

For large-scale testing, Mailforge allows you to quickly create hundreds or even thousands of mailboxes. While the minimum purchase is 10 mailbox slots at $13 per month (when billed yearly), bulk pricing can drop as low as $1.67 per mailbox for high-volume users. This efficiency provides a strong starting point for a comprehensive testing system.

Complete Testing Workflow with Forge Tools

Mailforge works best when paired with other Forge tools, creating a seamless workflow that covers every step of your A/B testing process - from lead generation to analyzing results.

Leadsforge is your go-to for building test audiences. Instead of reusing the same email list for every test (which can lead to list fatigue), you can generate fresh, targeted lead lists tailored to your campaigns. The tool’s intuitive, chat-like interface makes it easy to define criteria for different test groups, ensuring your audience represents your target market accurately.

Warmforge takes care of deliverability before your tests even begin. New domains and mailboxes need time to build credibility with email providers. Warmforge automates this process by gradually increasing sending volumes and interacting with other warmed accounts to establish trust. Without this step, poor deliverability could undermine your test results.

Salesforge is where you manage your test sequences. You can create multiple email variations, schedule automated follow-ups, and track performance metrics - all integrated directly with your Mailforge infrastructure. This eliminates the need for complex setups between tools.

Agent Frank takes automation to the next level by managing entire test campaigns from start to finish. This AI-powered SDR can source leads via Leadsforge, warm up domains with Warmforge, execute test sequences through Salesforge, and analyze results to optimize future campaigns. For companies juggling multiple A/B tests, Agent Frank ensures consistent execution while minimizing human error.

This integrated system streamlines the entire testing process. Agent Frank identifies your target audience, builds lead lists with Leadsforge, configures domains using Mailforge, warms them up via Warmforge, and runs test sequences in Salesforge. Once results roll in, it evaluates performance and adjusts future campaigns based on what’s working.

By eliminating technical roadblocks, this unified approach ensures your A/B tests run smoothly. Instead of switching between platforms and managing manual processes, you have a single system designed specifically for large-scale cold email testing.

The biggest advantage? Consistency across tests. Whether you're testing multiple elements or running simultaneous experiments, a standardized setup ensures that external factors don’t interfere with your results. This means your outcomes truly reflect performance differences, not inconsistencies in your infrastructure.

With this streamlined system in place, you can focus on refining your campaigns and achieving better results over time.

sbb-itb-fe3169b

Using Test Results to Improve Campaigns

A/B testing is only valuable if it leads to better campaigns. Businesses that consistently act on their test results report a 37% increase in ROI.

Reading Your Test Data

When analyzing your test results, focus on open rates, click-through rates, and conversions - but always consider the context. Statistical significance is key. Without it, you might mistake random variations for meaningful trends. For instance, a 5% improvement in open rates might look promising, but if it's not statistically significant, acting on it could backfire.

Zero in on the metrics that align with your goals. If your priority is booking more meetings, you might accept a slight dip in open rates if your reply rates show a noticeable jump.

Look for recurring patterns across multiple tests instead of treating each result as a one-off. For example, HubSpot discovered that left-aligned text underperformed, with fewer than 25% of left-aligned emails beating their centered text counterparts. Similarly, ongoing A/B testing can lead to a 40% improvement in email performance over time. The real skill lies in identifying which tweaks make a difference and which are just noise.

These insights lay the groundwork for a structured, repeatable testing process.

Creating a Testing System

Incorporate every test into a cycle of continuous improvement. Beyond setting clear goals, documenting each experiment is essential for refining your strategy.

Keep a record of every test - note the variations, results, and lessons learned. This builds a knowledge base that helps you optimize future campaigns more efficiently. Without proper documentation, you risk duplicating efforts or losing valuable insights.

Prioritize tests based on potential impact, confidence, and ease of execution. For instance, while testing subject lines is quick, you might get better results by focusing on call-to-action buttons if your subject lines are already performing well.

Design tests that build on previous findings. If personalized subject lines work well for your audience (emails with personalized subject lines are 26% more likely to be opened), follow up by testing other forms of personalization instead of reverting to generic messaging.

Before running a test, formulate a clear hypothesis and focus on a single measurable outcome. This approach helps you avoid distractions and gain a clearer picture of what drives results for your audience.

Tracking Test Performance

Once your testing system is in place, the next step is to monitor improvements over time. Testing email subject lines can increase open rates by 12.5%, while experimenting with CTAs can boost click-through rates by 127%. The benefits multiply when you consistently track and refine your efforts.

To make sense of your data, consider using comparison tables like this:

Test Element Variation A Variation B Winner Improvement Implementation Date
Subject Line "Quick question about [Company]" "[Name], 2-minute favor?" Variation B +18% open rate Jan 15, 2025
CTA Button "Let's chat" "Book 15 minutes" Variation B +34% click rate Feb 3, 2025
Send Time 9:00 AM EST 2:00 PM EST Variation A +22% reply rate Feb 20, 2025

Monitor subscriber behavior to identify trends and opportunities for improvement. For instance, if specific audience segments consistently respond better to certain approaches, tailor campaigns to match their preferences.

Additionally, track how frequently you test and the cumulative impact of these efforts. A/B testing isn't just about quick wins - it’s about refining your messaging over time. Consistent testing helps shape your communication into its most effective form. Companies that test more frequently often achieve better long-term results because they’re always improving.

Segment your analysis by factors like subscriber tenure, acquisition source, and engagement level to uncover patterns that can inform retention strategies. Tailoring your campaigns based on these insights ensures they resonate more effectively with your audience.

"Email marketing A/B testing has so many benefits, such as solving user problems and improving UX, driving growth and business impact, optimizing content for diverse audience segments as well as gaining insight and learnings you can apply to future campaigns." - Rob Gaer, Senior Software Engineer at Miro

The ultimate goal isn’t just to win individual tests - it’s to deepen your understanding of your audience and improve every campaign you send. By systematically tracking performance and applying insights, you build a foundation for ongoing success rather than relying on occasional lucky breaks.

A/B Testing Success in 2025

Achieving success with cold email A/B testing in 2025 hinges on three key elements: a structured testing approach, a dependable infrastructure, and a dedication to constant refinement.

At the heart of effective A/B testing lies a solid infrastructure. Tools like Mailforge, trusted by over 10,000 businesses, simplify large-scale testing with cost-efficient solutions that make setup a breeze. This kind of dependable infrastructure is essential for generating meaningful and actionable test results.

"We often hear 10x improvement as a target one among startups, when it comes to cold email infrastructure setup, Mailforge provides 100x improvement! Procedures that usually took hours (setting DKIM, SPF, etc. records) for multiple domains, now take a few minutes. Mailforge is also cost-efficient since you spend per mailbox ~3 times less than with Gmail. The support team replies in minutes and is happy to sort out issues in a proactive manner! Highly recommended for any organization where streamlined cold email infrastructure setup and scaling processes are needed." - Karlo Binda, Founder Leadsnack.co

Once the infrastructure is in place, running targeted A/B tests becomes much more straightforward. The key is to test one variable at a time to ensure clear and actionable insights. For instance, River Island used this focused approach to refine their email strategy, resulting in a 30.9% boost in revenue per email and a 26% increase in open rates, all while sending 22.5% fewer emails. This example illustrates how disciplined testing can not only sharpen your messaging but also lead to measurable, scalable improvements.

Top-performing companies treat A/B testing as a continuous process rather than a one-off exercise. Data shows that segmented campaigns achieve 14.31% higher open rates compared to non-segmented ones, while personalized emails can see up to 50% higher open rates than generic ones. These gains build over time when businesses consistently test and refine their strategies.

With email campaigns delivering an average ROI of $42 for every $1 spent, systematic testing is one of the smartest investments you can make. Keeping detailed records of your tests and learning from what works is crucial. For example, a SaaS company compared two subject lines - "Boost Your Productivity with [Tool Name]" and "Struggling with Time Management? Try This" - and found the latter, which focused on a pain point, delivered 25% higher open rates and 20% more replies.

It's also worth noting that 61% of decision-makers prefer cold emails over other communication methods. To maximize results, run tests for 7–14 days to gather reliable data, use clean email lists to ensure high deliverability, and always start with a clear hypothesis.

In 2025, successful businesses will combine tools like Mailforge with disciplined testing and a commitment to acting on insights. For example, following up 3–4 times can boost response rates by up to 27%, but only if your infrastructure supports the volume without compromising deliverability. By pairing reliable tools with a rigorous testing process, companies can achieve lasting success in cold email outreach.

FAQs

How can I make sure my A/B test results for cold emails are reliable and not just random?

To get dependable A/B testing results, it’s crucial to test just one variable at a time - whether that’s subject lines, CTAs, or the email content itself. This approach ensures you can pinpoint the exact effect of the change. Always run your tests simultaneously to eliminate any biases caused by timing, and ensure your sample size is big enough to yield reliable data.

Keep an eye on key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, or reply rates, depending on what you’re aiming to achieve. Tools like Mailforge can simplify this process by supporting consistent email deliverability and scalability. Following these practices minimizes random fluctuations and gives you more confidence in your findings.

How can I segment my email list to get better A/B testing results?

To get better results from your A/B testing, try segmenting your email list by grouping contacts based on factors like demographics, location, engagement levels, or purchase behavior. This approach makes your tests more focused and relevant.

You can take it a step further by segmenting based on lead score or sales funnel stage. This way, you can zero in on the groups that are most responsive, helping you fine-tune your campaigns for improved performance. By tailoring your segmentation, you'll gather more precise data and ultimately achieve stronger results with your cold email strategy.

How does Mailforge improve the success of A/B testing for cold email campaigns?

Mailforge helps make A/B testing more effective by offering a high-deliverability infrastructure. This ensures your email variations consistently reach your audience, allowing you to track performance accurately and compare test results with confidence.

Key features like automated DNS setup, domain masking, and bulk updates simplify the process of managing large-scale cold email campaigns. By focusing on improving deliverability and reducing the complexity of infrastructure management, Mailforge enables businesses to refine their email strategies and get more actionable insights from A/B testing.

Related posts